Does anyone here have a view as to which is best?We're getting quotes for the resurfacing of our drive (which is currently tarmaced -but surface is poor - it is probably close to 50 years old, and was damaged by heavy vehicles/ equipment when we had house underpinning done 15 years ago - they patched it with conrete!).One supplier recommends 25mm thickness of 6mm Stone Mastic Asphalt, rather than same thickness of 6mm dense surface course macadam (but he quoted for both). Says asphalt is less likely to deform in hot weather under the weight of vehicles.The second I suspect quoted for the asphalt option (as well as macadam) just because I mentioned the first supplier's comment.A third visited today, and rubbished the need for asphalt - said never uses it and 6mm macadam will not deform or wear in a domestic drive within a 15 year life.The first 2 quotes are approx £350 more expensive for asphalt. For that difference I would go for asphalt if it is indeed better. But is it?Many thanks for any insight / experience on this (or any tips on how to select best supplier!)CheersHGF
Well, I have to admit to not knowing the difference between the two materials.However, I had a drive laid with one* of them, and the material was course, because the finer stuff wasn't available that day. It was a mistake, as the gaps fill up with soil like stuff that allows moss to grow.I have noticed that the finer surfaces stay moss-free.It arrived hot and was rolled, if that is helpful?
This site often gets a mentionhttp://www.pavingexpert.com/tarmac01.htm2222
Why are you restricting yourself to tarmac or asphalt?Have you ruled out block paving, concrete?Also what about this option http://boards.fool.co.uk/new-driveway-11933369.aspx?sort=who...GO
I have not heard of SMA used for domestic driveways, although I suppose there is no reason in principle why you could not use it. 'Dense Bit' seems to be the standard material and is adequate in my view, unless you are designing for particularly high loads and/or hot weather.The Paving Expert site as recommended above is excellent. You might also have a look at this site aimed more at highway maintenance professionals, but very informative: http://www.highwaysmaintenance.com/Cheers,Gwyn
Which is more economical pricewise; block paving or tarmac/asphalt for a domestic drive?
Which is more economical pricewise; block paving or tarmac/asphalt for a domestic drive? If it helps, we're about to have our drive resurfaced with block paving (Global Stone York Green Old Rectory Cobbles to be precise). For digging out (including a soakaway) MOT Type 1 sub-base, strip gully, supply and wet lay the blocks we're paying £100 per sq metre. From memory, the cobbles account for about £40 per sq m of that but they come in "project packs" i.e. crates so there's a chance of having quite a bit left over.Other quotes were up to 2.5 times that sum.Archie
Thanks everyone for the replies. I think I'll go back round the suppliers again, and ask for customer refs, and see if that helps me decide. The drive runs between some new (and brilliantly laid) stone walling, so I think a plain surface would set that off better than block paving would.I'll give Stonebond a call, but their site doesn't show any installers near us (North Wilts). Our quotes for asphalt are up to £2900 for 160 sq m, so it looks from the linked thread that Stonebond is at least double the cost(?)Thanks againHGF
I think I'll go back round the suppliers again, and ask for customer refs, and see if that helps me decide. The drive runs between some new (and brilliantly laid) stone walling, so I think a plain surface would set that off better than block paving would.As you compare, be sure to look at similar installations to your own. A straight drive up to a garage (for example) will take very little wear. A curved drive, a lot more. And a large drive for several cars where 3 (or more)-point-turns are regularly undertaken will be subjected to a great deal of wheel scuffing as drivers go from lock to lock.You need to make sure your chosen surface stands up to the sort of use it will get in your situation. A "pretty" drive surface for a low-wear situation might get ripped to shreds after a few 3-pointers!
© Copyright 1998-2013, The Motley Fool Limited. All rights reserved. This material is for personal use only.The Motley Fool, Fool, and the "Fool" logo are registered trademarks of The Motley Fool, Inc.Place of Reg: England & Wales. Company Reg No: 3736872. VAT Reg No: 945 6990 68. Registered Office: 5th Floor, 60 Charlotte Street London W1T 2NU.
Page load time and server: