No. of Recommendations: 8
I counted 9 direct quotes in the list I gave you

Hmmm. Well, most are ad hominems and some insults. But here's one of them:

* Overpeck has no recollection of saying that he wanted to “get rid of the Medieval Warm Period”. Thinks he may have been quoted out of context.(1206628118)

This is in reference to a quote that has been circulating the sceptisphere for some years. 'We have to get rid of the Medieval Warm Period'. It is attributed to Overpeck by David Deeming in an email. But here is what the linked CRU mail actually says:

> > Hi Phil, Kevin, Mike, Susan and Ben - I'm looking
> > for some IPCC-related advice, so thanks in
> > advance. The email below recently came in and I
> > googled "We have to get rid of the warm medieval
> > period" and "Overpeck" and indeed, there is a
> > person David Deeming that attributes the quote to
> > an email from me. He apparently did mention the
> > quote (but I don't think me) in a Senate hearing.
> > His "news" (often with attribution to me) appears
> > to be getting widespread coverage on the
> > internet. It is upsetting.
> >
> > I have no memory of emailing w/ him, nor any
> > record of doing so
(I need to do an exhaustive
> > search I guess), nor any memory of him period. I
> > assume it is possible that I emailed w/ him long
> > ago, and that he's taking the quote out of
> > context, since I know I would never have said what
> > he's saying I would have, at least in the context
> > he is implying.

There, I've done the work for you. Remember this was posted (or copied) in response to a request for the worst examples of wrongdoing. So the obvious question is ... what was the point of posting this?
Print the post  


Call to Order for Climate Change
How discussion on this board should be conducted. Avoid having your post deleted... or worse.
Closure of the UK Discussion Boards
The UK Discussion Boards are now closed to new posts.